Ethiopia: Country For Sale! By Alemayehu G. Mariam

March 28th, 2011 Print Print Email Email

The Deal of the Century

Supposing someone offered you the following land deal, would you take it or walk away believing it is too good to be true? For £150 a week (USD$245), you can lease more than 2,500 sq km (1,000 sq miles) of virgin, fertile land – an area the size of Dorset, England – for 50 years, plus generous tax breaks.

If you walked away from it, you would have lost out on “the deal of the century”, perhaps the millennium. If you think this is a joke or some sort of wild and crazy exaggeration, see this Guardian (U.K.) report and video on an incredible international land giveaway that is taking place in Gambella in Western Ethiopia and judge for yourself.

Ethiopia on the Chopping Block

The Indian agribusiness giant Karuturi Global is today the proud owner of 1,000 sq. miles of virgin Ethiopian land. Karuturi did not ask for the land and did not even see it when a signed 50-year “lease” was delivered to its offices in Bangalore, India on a golden platter by Meles Zenawi, the dictator-in-chief in Ethiopia. Karuturi Project Manager in Ethiopia Karmjeet Sekhon laughed euphorically as he explained what happened to Guardian reporter John Vidal:

We never saw the land. They gave it to us and we took it. Seriously, we did. We did not even see the land. (Triumphantly cackling laughter) They offered it. That’s all.
It’s very good land. It’s quite cheap. In fact it is very cheap. We have no land like this in India. There [India] you are lucky to get 1% of organic matter in the soil. Here it is more than 5%. We don’t need fertiliser or herbicides. There is absolutely nothing that will not grow on it. To start with there will be 20,000 hectares of oil palm, 15,000 hectares of sugar cane and 40,000 hectares of rice, edible oils and maize and cotton. We are building reservoirs, dykes, roads, towns of 15,000 people. This is phase one. In three years time we will have 300,000 hectares cultivated and maybe 60,000 workers. We could feed a nation here.

Ethiopia is on fire sale. Everybody is getting a piece of her. For next to nothing. The land vultures have been swooping down on Gambella from all parts of the world. Zenawi proudly claims “36 countries including India, China, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia have leased farm land.” The Guardian reported that “foreign investors” have snagged.

1.1 million hectares in Gambella, nearly a quarter of its best farmland, and 896 companies have come to the region in the last three years…. This month [March 2011] the concessions are being worked at a breakneck pace, with giant tractors and heavy machinery clearing trees, draining swamps and ploughing the land in time to catch the next growing season. Forests across hundreds of square km are being clear-felled and burned to the dismay of locals and environmentalists concerned about the fate of the region’s rich wildlife.
Karuturi, “one of the world’s top 25 agri-businesses” plans to “export palm oil, sugar, rice and other foods from Gambella province to world markets.”

Villagization of Gambella and the Irony of History

To make way for Karuturi and the 896 investors, the people of Gambella must be removed permanently from their ancestral lands. Over the past three years, tens of thousands of villagers have been forced to move as part of a so-called villagization program. Zenawi’s agriculture official said “there is no movement of population” in Gambella. It is the “choice” of the people to move to “villagized” centers where they can get basic services. Once they move, the official said, “they have to abandon their previous way of life, and they can’t ever go back to their villages”. Simply stated, Zenawi has imposed a contract on the indigenous people of Gambella: They will “voluntarily” choose to give up their ancestral lands, their culture and their community in exchange for a clinic, a school and a road.

“Villagization” (sefera) has a sinister and ugly history in Ethiopia. In the iron fists of the military junta (Derg) that ruled Ethiopia from the mid-1970s until 1991, “villagization” was a political and tactical counter-insurgency weapon. The Derg “villagized” and “resettled” populations in rebel-controlled areas to deny local support to rebels and create buffer zones. The Derg, like Zenawi’s regime today, justified its “villagization” program as a “development” and humanitarian effort aimed at providing food, clean water, health and educational services to needy populations.

At the onset of the 1984 famine, the Derg sought to resettle 1.5 million people from insurgent-controlled and drought-affected northern regions to the south and southwest of the country. The Derg said the people were relocating voluntarily. The northern insurgents, who now wield power, told the Derg victims of resettlement that they were being moved to concentration camps and will never return to the land where they were born (“where their umbilical cord was buried” to use the local metaphor in translation). It is an irony of history that in 2011 we hear the same old story: The people of Gambella are “voluntarily” leaving their ancestral lands and abandoning their traditional way of life in exchange for “clean water, health and educational services” in villagized centers.

The Derg never asked people (plebiscite) if they wanted to be resettled or remain on their ancestral land. Zenawi’s regime did not ask the indigenous people of Gambella if they want to be permanently uprooted from their ancestral lands and be “villagized” or corralled into reservations. The Derg could not have cared less about the people it was resettling as long as the resettlement policy advanced its counter-insurgency strategy. Zenawi could not care less about the indigenous people of Gambella as long it advanced his investment strategy. It is all about war or money. The Derg never did an environmental and human ecological impact study before it moved masses of people from the north to the southern part of the country. Zenawi’s regime never did a credible ecological study before uprooting the indigenous people of Gambella. Tens of thousands of people died in the Derg’s resettlement program from illness and starvation. Families were separated as people fled the ill-equipped and ill-managed resettlement centers. But the indigenous people of Gambella face extinction as a minority in Ethiopian society. So says a 2006 UNICEF field study:
The deracination [uprooting from ancestral lands] of indigenous people that is evident in rural areas of Gambella is extreme. It is very likely that Anuak (and possibly other indigenous minorities) culture will completely disappear in the not-so-distant future. Cultural survival, autonomy, rights of self-determination and self-governance are all legitimate issues for these indigenous groups, and these are al enshrined by international covenants and United Nations bodies—but all are meaningless in

Gambella today. It is true that history repeats itself over and over again!

When the Derg implemented its “villagization” and “resettlement” programs in the 1980s as a counterinsurgency strategy, it was not only morally wrong, it was criminal. It is no different for Zenawi in 2011 to “villagize” the indigenous people of Gambella and give away their ancestral lands for free to foreign investors who did not even ask for it. If it was a crime against humanity for Derg leader Mengistu to depopulate the northern rebel-controlled regions as part of his counterinsurgency strategy, it is no less a crime against humanity for Zenawi to depopulate Gambella to make way for his “investments.” Mengistu was convicted of genocide by Zenawi in substantial part for Mengistu’s use of “resettlement” and “villagization” as a tool of counterinsurgency. Mengistu never believed he would be held accountable; and today Zenawi similarly believes he will never be held accountable. But sometimes “justice is like a train that always arrives late.” Justice will soon arrive for the indigenous people of Gambella.

The Gambella Gambit

History shows that the indigenous people of Gambella have been neglected, discriminated and exploited over centuries of successive administrations in Ethiopia. But it was in December 2003 that the public rape of Gambella became known to the whole world. Before taking Gambella’s “best farmland”, they took the lives of hundreds of Gambella’s best and brightest over a three-day period that December. As Obang Metho, the tireless and tenacious young Ethiopian human rights advocate who was born in Gambella described it:
They targeted those individuals who were the voices of the community and have a say in the exploration and development of oil on their land. The killing squads went through Gambella town looking for the next Anuak to brutally kill, they chanted, ‘Today there will be no more Anuak.’ ‘Today there will be no more Anuak land.’ As they raped the women they said, ‘Today there will be no more Anuak babies.’ Within three days, 424 Anuak were dead.
When I received news, it was the darkest day of my life. My world was turned upside down. Among the 424 Anuak killed, I personally knew 317 of them. They were my family, my classmates and many others with whom I had been working to bring development not just to the Anuak, but to the region. Most were educated and outspoken. I have no doubts that I would have been one of the victims had I been living there at the time.

Genocide Watch described this massacre as a “major pogrom of terror and repression against the Anuak minority carried out by EPRDF soldiers and Highlander militias.” Human Rights Watch concluded: “Since late 2003, the Ethiopian National Defense Force (ENDF) has committed numerous human rights violations against Anuak communities in the Gambella region of southwestern Ethiopia that may amount to crimes against humanity.” The Anuak Justice Council reported “genocide and crimes against humanity have continued, raising the death toll between 1,500 and 2,500, and causing more than 50,000 Anuak to flee.”

Ethiopian Developers are Criminals, Indian Investors are Heroes?

A couple of weeks ago, Zenawi condemned Ethiopian developers who were transferring their leaseholds in urban land in Addis Ababa as “land grabbers” and “speculators” who should be “locked up”. He said “developers were grabbing land that does not belong to them in any legal sense and misusing the land lease rights they were given for personal profit and speculation.” In Zenawi’s eyes, Ethiopian developers are low-down, no good, two-bit cheaters, scammers and profiteers; but Indian investors who are given millions of hectares of the “best land” in the country without asking and for nothing are heroes and saviors.
But this is not about Ethiopian developers against Indian investors. It is not about the rights of local against international investors. It is about fairness and equity. It is about official wrongs and the human rights of some of the poorest, historically oppressed, discriminated and exploited indigenous minorities in Ethiopia. It is about a land giveaway of mind-boggling proportions to a foreign company to raise rice, edible oils, maize and cotton for export while millions of Ethiopians are starving and living on international food handouts. (In 2010, Ethiopia “received more than 700,000 tonnes of food and £1.8bn in aid, but has offered three million hectares (7.4 million acres) of virgin land to foreign corporations such as Karuturi.”) It is about making “land deals of the century” without accountability, transparency, public debate, discussion and, above all, the consent of the people who will be permanently displaced from their ancestral lands. It is about how a whole country became the personal investment property of one man and his syndicate!

Karuturi, Beware of Those Bearing Free Gifts

I will never forget the giddy, bearded-face of Karuturi Project Manager in Gambella, Karmjeet Sekhon, in the Guardian video giggling ecstatically and telling John Vidal about the free land his company got: “We never saw the land. They gave it to us and we took it. Seriously, we did. We did not even see the land. They offered it. That’s all.”
Sorry, Karuturi and Mr. Sekhon, “that is not all.” You ain’t seen nothing yet!
Of course, Karuturi is free to indulge in the proverbial fantasy about a free lunch, free money and free land. Just as there is no such thing as a free lunch, there is no such thing as free land. After Karturi spends millions to clear the forest, bring in expensive agricultural equipment, build infrastructure and get the farms humming, it will find out “that’s not all”. Mr. Sekhon will wake up one fine Gambella morning and find out that the free land his company got without asking ain’t free after all. Karuturi will find out that it has failed to get this or that permit, or is in violation of this or that part of the 50-year lease. It did not build this school or that clinic, and the ones it built are not big enough or good enough. It will find out that it did not build this road or that town center the right way, and the ones it built are inadequate and more need to be built. Karuturi will suddenly find out that foreign investment law that gave them millions of hectares of free land has been reinterpreted to mean whatever the free land-givers want it to mean, just like the urban land law was interpreted to mean that developers could be “locked up” for trying to transfer their leaseholds for profit or pay “hefty fines” to avoid jail time. In the end, Mr. Sekhon’s words will come back to haunt him and his company: “The hand that gaveth the free land is the hand that taketh away the fine, well-developed farmland!”

Karuturi and the rest of the “investors” have no idea how cunning, shrewd, tricky, wily and crafty the free land-givers are; and they do not learn from self-evident facts. Those who are handing out free land understand the power of greed in the hearts and minds of the greedy. Mr. Sekhon was as giddy and merry as a five-year old child who was just got handed a bagful of candy. All of the investors salivate at the idea of grabbing millions of hectares of free land. Their greed blinds them to a self-evident truth: It is impossible to get a whole lot of something (1,000 sq miles of virgin, fertile land) for a whole lot of nothing ($245 a week for 50 years, plus generous tax breaks).

In the end, all of the investors will lose. In the end, the free land-givers will have it all. Over the decades, we have seen free-land-for-nothing type of scams from Angola to Zimbabwe. On March 27, 2011, Robert Mugabe told foreign investors straight-up that he is going to muscle in on their mining operations in Zimbabwe:
We are taking over. Listen Britain and America: this is our country. If you have companies which would want to work in our mining sector, they are welcome to come and join us, but we must have our people as the major shareholders. Those whites who want to be with us, those outsiders who want to work with us fine, they come in as partners, we are the senior partner, no more the junior partner.
Like Mugabe, Ethiopia’s free land-givers will watch the international investors pour their money, hearts and skills into the lands. They will study every move the investors make, and then make their own move. Soon enough, Karuturi and Mr. Sekhon and the rest of them will figure out that they are “outsiders” (not investors) and the free land-givers will “take over” the farming operations, or at least become “senior partners” for giving them free land in the first place. That’s how it will all play out. It has happened time and again all over Africa. Any written lease contract with Karuturi and the rest of them will not be worth the paper it is written on. Whatever unwritten agreements there may be, they will be conveniently forgotten. By the time the investors figure out that they had been taken to the cleaners, it would too late. Mr. Sekhon, who giggled uncontrollably for getting hundreds of thousands of hectares of free land will cry uncontrollably all the way back to Bangalore, India to tell his bosses: “We should have known it was too good to be true! We should have….” The guys who gave out millions of free hectares without anyone asking them for it will be laughing all the way to the bank in London, New York and Zurich.

Cry for the Beloved Country

When hundreds of Anuaks were massacred in Gambella in 2003, the international human rights organizations stepped forward to let the world know what happened there. In 2011, the Guardian newspaper bared to the world the imminent danger facing the indigenous people of Gambella. Over the years, I have tried to offer my voice of support to the cause of Anuak human rights and condemned the giveaway of the ancestral lands for nothing to foreign investors. I shall cry for all the people of Gambella. I shall cry for the Anuak because I fear, as does UNICEF, that they are undergoing a slow genocide by cultural annihilation and dispossession of ancestral lands. The indigenous people of Gambella will forever lose their pastoral way of life, and the new generation of young Gambellans will never know the traditional ways of their forefathers. I shall cry for the precious wild life that will never return because their habitat has been permanently destroyed, and for the bountiful forests that are burned to ashes to make commercial farmland and the rivers and fishes that will be poisoned with pesticide and herbicide to grow rice and cotton for export. I shall cry out to the heavens for Ethiopia, for she has become the personal investment property of Meles Zenawi, just like the Congo was the personal investment property of King Leopold II of Belgium in the late 1800s.

But this is no time to despair and submit to the arrogance of power and the power of arrogance. The trials and tribulations of the indigenous people of Gambella and their 80 million compatriots shall come to pass soon; and the bright sun that is lifting the darkness over North Africa and the Middle East is dawning just over the horizon over the land of 13 months of sunshine. Let them all stand up, hold hands, march together and cast away their fears into the fierce blowing winds of change.

  1. Mad man Meles!
    | #1

    Heartbreaking! Thank you again professor Alemayehu for this great article. Your article should be read by every Ethiopian in and outside of Ethiopia. I hope it gets translated into Amharic, Oromijna and Tigrenja and distributed in all around Ethiopia. It is about time every Ethiopian come to know the despicable crimes Meles has been committing on Ethiopia and Ethiopians in everyday basis since he came to power. Meles is indeed worse than foreign enemies. My heart bleeds for my country Ethiopia, especially to the Ethiopians who are directly affected in Gambela and Gondar. Meles has abused his power and committed more crimes on his people than the Egyptian, Libyan, Yemeni, and Tunisian dictators put together. The brutal tyrant and mad man Meles must go now!

  2. Andinet Godana
    | #2

    The fact is Meles Zenawi is not Robert Mugabe or one of the nationalist African leaders. Melees interest is based on hatred; and disrespect his own fellow “country men and women”. Where are the banks or mortgage companies? or even the agricultural institution’s? $245 a week? my mortgage is way above than that.
    In a country like Ethiopia, where former bandits and illiterates form a party based on ethnicity and call themselves “government” that’s where the problem begins, with one party rule a dictator with a nationalist hidden agenda any thing can go wrong.
    It is sad to see Ethiopia has a laughing stock ruler who doesn’t know any thing about the wheel and deal of world business.
    How come i confront my fellow Indian co-workers Knowing that i am from Ethiopia? what a shame .

  3. aha!
    | #3

    Thanks for elaborating on the invesigative reporting by the Guardian. After devatating the pristine forest ecosystem by TPLF/eprdf regime, they have now resorted to devatating the pristine forest ecosystem in Gambela as a steward of the pristine forest lands both from the stand point of conservation and sequestration of CO2, contributing to global warming to leasind land to ammass foreign currency. Add to that the disruption of the harmonious exisitence of the ethnic groups in the region. Add to that the assignment of ethnic boundries and ethnic federalism and secessionism of self rule and separate development and yet do not have a say into the development of the region by foeign investors, shipping the products to their own country to enjoy a second time green revolution with foreign land resource as their means of production, when theirs have reached a diminishing return.

    Having said I will reinforce your conclusion by the Ethiopians to unite over a clear cut goals for unity, territorial integrity, sovereignity of Ethiopia and Ethiopians to restore Ethiopian Nationalism and Ethiopian National Interests as awhole, using the same strategies. This makes your call for “Let us stand up, hold hands, march together, cast away their “your” fears of winds of change, a reality, using a clear cut goals and strategies in in a “Non-violent reaction to freedom” from authocratic, ethnocratic/ethnic dictatorship, totalitarian regime from its Marxist ideology of the Dergue regime and an apatheid system of governance and/or adminstration for the most part.

  4. Dimocrat
    | #4

    I respect you , BRAVO BRAVO , Please tell agin & again , I`m reading all the time your commentary and I`m proud of you..
    Danke Danke !!

  5. Dan
    | #5

    “Like Mugabe , Ethiopia ’s free land-givers will watch the international investors pour their money, hearts and skills into the lands. They will study every move the investors make, and then make their own move. Soon enough, Karuturi and Mr. Sekhon and the rest of them will figure out that they are “outsiders” (not investors) and the free land-givers will “take over” the farming operations, or at least become “senior partners” for giving them free land in the first place.”

    Here I am not sure What Al’s position is? How long is Mr Mugabe going to wait to RIGHT the wrongs of history? Isn’t the land question the last colonial question that need to be resolved? And attorney Al is warning us that the Meles Dictatorship has the intention of swindling the Indians Investors by doing Mugabe on them. Is that supposed to comfort us? cause Mugabe took the land back??

    [[..The deracination [upr[ooting from ancestral lands] of indigenous people that is evident in rural areas of Gambella is extreme. It is very likely that Anuak (and possibly other indigenous minorities) culture will completely disappear in the not-so-distant future]]

    Is it a coincidence that Al and the “environmentalist” talk in the same language?

    >>”indigenous peoples”, it is only because they regard them as part of the natural kingdom rather than human society. They view them as integral to the local ecosystem, which they want to keep untouched by modernity’s apparently corrupting forces…<>..The tours are like human safaris. Visitors drive from village to village on dirt roads, taking snaps of curious dark tribes – such as the Surma, whose women walk around topless and wear clay lip plates….>>

    I am skepitcal about the The Guardain guy – I think he is more worried that the Deal of the Century, was made by an Indian instead of another Western Multi National.

    It is obvious that Karuturi’s Project Manager was played like a stupid fool.

    Karturi holds a US MBA and is smart business man. The Meles Dictatorship is the Land Lord, Why wouldn’t Karturi make his land lords happy? Regardless of the deal already made, I don’t see why the Dictatorship won’t demand a similar concession as Alamoudi’s? If not Karturi will end up like Petranos, nothing to export,,,,or farm…

    All agreements are as good as who is behind them. Both the Meles Dictatorship and Karturi know the game.

    If Al just concentrated on the legitmate Human Right issue of the Anuak instead of mixing apples and oranges he would have scored better. BTW, the way Al trashed Meles on Contract Law last week was awsome!!

  6. Mike
    | #6

    Not sure what the motive is behind this article. It seems you do not want 896 investors from investing millions of dollars to develop a country and make is self sufficient and be an export oriented economy. The world is changing too fast. Hope whatever is the right thing for the people of Ethopia happens.

  7. amlakaman
    | #7

    To hate Meles is one thing , but to be obsessed like the so called professor is insane . I believe this guy has a serious mental problem . I watched one of his presentations on line and I was so disappointed at the self claimed prof. I did not see any thing to convince me that he is physically or mentally qualified to represent any Ethiopian . Please go online under alemayehu g/meriam watch the video and judge for your self . He reminds me of Mr . Gadaffi to say the list . at list Gaddafi is a hero to his people sort of.
    Brother Al. why don/t you just get out of the way and leave Ethiopia to the vibrant youth in and out of the country old people like you are obsolete like a commodity .Time to get lost buddy .

  8. Anonymous
    | #8

    Ethiopia has also its shares of plenty selfish, greedy, irrational and cold hearted citizens like #5 Mike who blindly support disgraced tyrants like in Egypt, Tunisia, Libya, Yemen, Syria etc. The likes of Mike don’t care how the majority of Ethiopians struggle, suffer, looted, lost their land, tortured and killed as long as Meles, Azeb and the members of TPLf have everything their little hearts desire at the expenses of Ethiopian Tax Payers. Shame!Shame!Shame!

  9. Clueless Woyanes!
    | #9

    You would have been better off if Abugida keep on deleting your stupid comments. You have a nerve to criticize and belittle an accomplished law abiding patriotic Ethiopian like Professor Alemayehu and at the same time you’re a staunch supporter of a dictator who has the blood of countless number of Ethiopians, that has looted the country blind and thrown tens of thousands Ethiopians in prison to be tortured and killed. Besides Human Rights Abuse and atrocities that have been committed on Ethiopians in the last 20 years, the country Ethiopia under TPLF regime have been rated one of the poorest and backward countries in the world. How pathetic that you are measuring the country’s growth and advancement by how much Woyanes have gotten rich by looting 76 million Ethiopians! Totally moronic and delusional! Yes, there are a handful uninformed traitors like Solomon Tekalegane out there, but you are gravely mistaken to think that the majority of Ethiopians would buy your propaganda. The fact that you are trying to convince Ethiopians with your brainwashing tactics tells us a lot how clueless and arrogant you are. Ethiopians had enough of TPLF lies, looting, selling our land and most of all the unspeakable crimes and genocide that have been committed on Ethiopians in Gambella and around Ethiopia. Now it is clear than ever before for all Ethiopians that the TPLF regime are thousands times worse than Derg.
    Amlakaman, I suggest you stop wasting your worthless time on Abugida to convince Ethiopians about one the Ethiopian Hitler and the brutal TPLF regime. Have you been watching the news lately about dictators? Get a clue!

  10. Mekuria
    | #10

    The land grab issue has proven that the current government of Ethiopia is made up of the most dishonest people. Instead of defending the undefendable, they should resort to rectifying what’s wrong. Inviting land grabbers is bad for the politics of the regime. It’s bad for Ethiopia. Admit giving Ethiopia’s fertile lands almost for free is wrong, and the regime must stop giving more lands. Nobody with a healthy mind buys land grabbing is part of the development propaganda. We know what development constitutes. Land grabbing is not development; it’s exploitation of the worst order that will impoverish Ethiopians for generations.

Comments are closed.