Supporting Stability, Abetting Repression By TOBIAS HAGMANN

July 11th, 2012 Print Print Email Email

BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA — Next time I travel to Ethiopia, I may be arrested as a terrorist. Why? Because I have published articles about Ethiopian politics.

I wrote a policy report on Ethiopia’s difficulties with federalism. I gave a talk in which I questioned Ethiopia’s May 2010 elections, in which the ruling EPRDF party (Ethiopian Peoples’ Revolutionary Democratic Front) won 545 out of 547 seats in the Parliament. As part of my ongoing research on mass violence in the Somali territories, I interviewed members of the Ogaden National Liberation Front, a separatist rebel group in eastern Ethiopia that the government has designated as a terrorist organization.

In the eyes of the government of Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, my work is tantamount to subversion. Not only do his officials have zero tolerance for criticism, they consider people who either talk to or write about the opposition as abetting terrorists.

In recent years the government has effectively silenced opposition parties, human rights organizations, journalists and researchers. On June 27 a federal court convicted the journalist Eskinder Nega and 23 opposition politicians for “participation in a terrorist organization.” More than 10 other journalists have been charged under an anti-terrorism law introduced in 2009. Among them are two Swedes, Martin Schibbye and Johan Persson, who are serving an 11-year prison sentence in Ethiopia. Hundreds of opposition supporters languish in prisons for exercising the very democratic rights that the Ethiopian Constitution nominally protects.

Most people outside Ethiopia associate the country with famine and poverty. They know little about the country’s history and politics — for example that Ethiopia was never colonized, or that it has Africa’s second biggest population. Nor are they aware that Ethiopia is a darling of the donor community, receiving more aid than any other African country. Over the past year alone, the U.S. Agency for International Development has given Ethiopia $675 million in aid. The United States closely collaborates with Ethiopia in covert missions against radical Islamists in neighboring Somalia.

Much of this support comes from the portrayal of Ethiopia as a strong and stable government in a region riddled with political upheaval. The problem, however, is that Ethiopia is plagued by too much state control.

When EPRDF came to power in 1991, it promised to democratize the country. Two decades later the party has a tight grip on all public institutions, from the capital to remote villages. Formally a federal democracy, Ethiopia is a highly centralized one-party state. No independent media, judiciary, opposition parties or civil society to speak of exist in today’s Ethiopia. Many of the country’s businesses are affiliated with the ruling party. Most Ethiopians do not dare to discuss politics for fear of harassment by local officials.

As I found out in dozens of interviews with Ethiopian Somalis, security forces indiscriminately kill, imprison and torture civilians whom they suspect of aiding Ogaden rebels.

How have donors who fund about one third of Ethiopia’s budget and many humanitarian programs reacted to this? They haven’t. They not only continue to support the Ethiopian government but in recent years have increased their aid. The West, most prominently the United States and the European Union, have concluded a strange pact with Meles Zenawi: So long as his government produces statistics that evince economic growth, they are willing to fund his regime — whatever its human rights abuses.

This policy is wrong, shortsighted and counterproductive. It is wrong because billions in Western tax money are spent to support an authoritarian regime. It is shortsighted because it ignores the fact that the absence of basic rights and freedoms is one of the reasons Ethiopians are so poor. It is counterproductive because many Ethiopians resent the unconditional aid and recognition given to their rulers. In Ethiopia — and also in Rwanda and Uganda — the West is once again making the mistake of rewarding stability and growth while closing its eyes to repression.

Tobias Hagmann specializes in East African politics. He is a visiting scholar at the Department of Political Science at the University of California at Berkeley.

  1. koster
    | #1

    Fascist Meles Zenawi, donor darling is terrorizing the Ethiopian people inside and outside the country. He even tries to eliminate what he considers as enemies even in other African countries. It is very unfortunate that the USA/UK who claim to be guardians of freedom and democracy breed fascists “friendly tyrants” to use their term which terrorize their people. Tigrai Liberation Front the terrorist organization lead by Meles Zenawi is the al Quadia of the Horn of Africa and for sure it will be a great meanace not only for Ethiopia but for the region and beyond.
    The US/UK lost their darlings like Mobutu and Mubarek and it is now fascist Meles their only representative/darling.

  2. BIRI
    | #2

    — On Sun, 15/7/12, Biri Yaya wrote:

    From: Biri Yaya
    Subject: Re: [Ethiopians-Forum] Fw: If Seye Abraha, Birtukan Midekssa and General Kemal Gelchu were to lead as care Taker Transitional Council
    Date: Sunday, 15 July, 2012, 7:59

    Greetings All:
    It is obvious that tyrant MZ is about to die or be in a vegetative state or is to be invalid in a significant way.
    In realisation of this misfortune for the ruling mafia, several groupings within the TPLF are gearing up to protect their undeserved vested interests and to reform and maintain the status quo.
    But the groups continue to show contempt for Ethiopians at large.
    This may lead to a period of a paralysis and a sudden collapse of the mafia(Girma, do not jump in to say the collapse of Ethiopia!).
    To prevent this scenario, I would like to propose a totally out of box temporary arrangement:

    1. That the TPLF/EPRDF seek sponsors’ support for a period of a hand over to a Carer Taker Administration to an all-inclusive and unifying Council.
    I suggest that this Council be formed of Birtukan Midekssa( PM), Seye Abraha( Defence Minster), Brigadier General Kemal Gelchu, (President), Dr Berhanu Nega, (Foreign Minster), Eskinder Nega(minster of info and media).

    They would appoint a cabinet composed of stakeholders.

    2. The current regime would provide opportunity for reconciliation beginning with the release of all political prisoners. In exchange, the Council would move a motion for amnesty for MZ/family and those who served under him where crimes against humanity were not committed.

    In any event, nobody should be accused of any wrong doing until a legitimate courts of law are established.

    3. The Council would prepare the ground for a multi-party federal govt.

    4. The Council would declare an end of hostility with Eritrea and urge the Isaias Afeworki of the Eritrean Govt to agree to reconciliation, but would not sign any treaty until a legitimate all-inclusive Ethiopian Govt has come into existence.

    5. The Council would reform the Electoral Commission…as a way of paving the way for a legitimate process.
    Any comments?
    Sent from my BlackBerry® wireless device

Comments are closed.